The problem does not lie in the absence of law. The problem lies in the fact that its application in specific situations leads to conclusions that are not intuitive for either employers or foreigners themselves and – most importantly – generate real legal and financial consequences. In many cases, we are not dealing with abuse or circumvention of the law, but with a system that itself produces risk.
One of the most problematic elements is how applications for stay legalization are handled. In practice, they are often submitted by mail and reach the office, where they are accepted but not immediately verified for completeness. This means that, for a certain period, they exist in the system, even though their formal effectiveness has not yet been confirmed.
This stage is crucial. A foreigner who submitted an application benefits from procedural protection and may continue residing in Poland, and in practice may also continue working. From an administrative perspective, this is rational – it avoids blocking foreigners at the formal stage and allows them to complete missing documents.
The problem arises when the office, often after many weeks or months, requests supplementary action, such as personal attendance and fingerprint submission. If the foreigner fails to respond, does not appear at the office, or leaves Poland in the meantime, the application remains unprocessed, effectively considered ineffective.
At this point, a fundamental cause-and-effect problem arises. If the application turns out to be ineffective, the procedural basis for the foreigner’s stay disappears. Consequently, their status may be retroactively challenged, even though at the time of starting work they operated under the available procedures.
For the foreigner, this means a loss of continuity in their legal stay and potential difficulties in future proceedings. For the employer, the consequences are even more severe. Employment that was lawful at the moment of commencement may later be challenged. Importantly, the employer has no tools to ensure that the foreigner will comply with administrative requests or remain in the country. Yet the employer bears the legal risk.
Thus, the system creates a situation where it allows conditional legality of stay during the procedure, but failure to complete it produces consequences transferred to a party that has no influence on the outcome.
Another example of system inconsistency is how employment parameters specified in legalization documents are treated. Statements or work permits indicate a specific number of working hours, intended to reflect planned employment.
In practice, however, especially in sectors such as production, logistics, or agriculture, flexibility is required. Sometimes the employee wants to work more, and the employer is able to provide this. Work is performed, wages are paid, and all public dues are settled.
The problem arises in interpretation. In some legal opinions, exceeding the indicated number of hours is considered working beyond the scope of legalization. This means that any extra hours may be deemed illegal work.
This mechanism is particularly problematic because it does not concern hiding employment or tax avoidance. It concerns a situation where all work is transparent and fully accounted for but does not match formally declared parameters. Consequently, it can be equated with “off-the-books” employment.
For the foreigner, this carries the risk of being considered as working outside permit conditions, which may affect their future status. For the employer, it carries the risk of liability for illegal employment, even when all obligations have been met. The core problem is the lack of distinction between abuse and natural labor flexibility.
A clear example of systemic inconsistency was the situation of Colombian citizens entering Poland under the visa-free scheme. From August 15, 2024, a practice emerged according to which citizens of Colombia should not use entry based on biometrics.
It is important to note that at the time of this practice, no formal legal change occurred. No new act or regulation directly addressed the issue. This was not a change of law, but a change in interpretation.
The consequences were tangible. Depending on the regional office, identical factual circumstances were assessed differently. In some offices, applications submitted by Colombians entering after that date were automatically rejected. In other cases, positive decisions were issued. Furthermore, many negative decisions were overturned during appeals, undermining system uniformity.
For the foreigner, this created unpredictability and required engagement in lengthy appeal procedures. For the employer, it was even more challenging, as they could not assess employment risk. The same employee profile in the same factual situation could be considered legal or illegal depending on which office handled the case.
Only later were regulations introduced to formally reflect this practice. During the transition, the system operated in a state of factual inconsistency, where interpretation preceded legislation.
Another problematic area is administrative process organization. Despite digitalization, a significant part of documents is still submitted in paper form. In practice, this means a document may be delivered, accepted, and stamped, but for some time not appear in the IT system.
This gap between physical submission and system registration has concrete consequences. A foreigner may have proof of submission and receipt but be told that the case does not exist. This is not a substantive error, but an organizational delay.
From the employer’s perspective, this prevents verification of employee status. Even with due diligence, the employer cannot confirm if the case is being processed because it is formally not in the system. The risk of misinterpretation rises, even though all actions were properly taken.
The final component of the problem is inconsistent practice among offices. This concerns both the interpretation of regulations and how decisions are documented or how a foreigner’s status is confirmed.
In practice, documents in similar cases may differ in form and evidential value. For an employer, who must make operational decisions based on these documents, this means the need for interpretation, increasing the risk of error.
The formal system, based on documentation, loses functionality if these documents are not uniform and unambiguous.
In all these cases, the same mechanism is visible. The foreigner and employer act in accordance with available procedures, the system allows certain actions, and then – due to interpretation, delay, or independent events – the assessment of the same situation changes.
The consequences of this change are unevenly distributed. In practice, they primarily burden the employer and the foreigner – the parties with the least influence on system functioning.
First, it is necessary to clearly define the moment when stay and work lose legality. Failure to complete the application should trigger effects from the moment of non-compliance, not retroactively affect periods during which the foreigner operated under an accepted procedure.
Second, employment parameters should allow permissible deviations instead of rigid figures. This would distinguish actual abuses from natural labor flexibility and reduce cases of formally legal work being treated as illegal.
Third, administrative practice should be linked to legislation and standardized. Situations such as those emerging on August 15, 2024, should not exist in a legal vacuum. If the application of law changes, it should immediately be reflected in binding regulations and applied uniformly across all offices.